Analysis of the Reference Value of Third-Party Valuation Signal Tools for Investment Decisions of Private Equity Firms like TPG

Based on in-depth research on TPG Inc. (TPG) and characteristic analysis of third-party valuation tools such as InvestingPro, I will systematically evaluate the reference value of such tools for investment decisions of private equity firms from multiple dimensions.

According to brokerage API data [0], TPG indeed showed strong stock price performance in 2024:

• Annual increase
  : From an opening price of 42.80 USD to a closing price of 62.84 USD in 2024, with an increase of
  46.82%
• Performance after April
  : From 45.28 USD on April 1, 2024 to 62.84 USD on December 31, with an increase of
  38.78%
• Current status
  (December 2025): Stock price 65.45 USD, market capitalization 25.09 billion USD

TPG’s core financial indicators show [0]:

Financial Indicator	Value	Evaluation
Management Fee Income (2024)	1.64 billion USD	Accounts for 78.5% of revenue
Assets Under Management (AUM)	245.9 billion USD	Industry-leading
Net Profit Margin	1.71%	Relatively low
ROE	3.51%	Average capital efficiency
P/E Ratio (TTM)	168.94x	Significantly overvalued

According to web search data [1][2], tools like InvestingPro provide:

:

• Integrates
  17 institutional-level valuation models
  (DCF, relative valuation, historical valuation center, etc.)
• Automatically calculates fair value range
• Provides overvalued/undervalued/reasonable judgments

: A German market case shows [1] that FRoSTA AG was marked as “undervalued” in November 2024 (stock price 60 EUR, fair value 88 EUR, potential upside 47%), and one year later the stock price rose to 99.80 EUR, with an actual return of 61.33%.

:

• AI stock selection strategy covers over 60,000 stocks globally
• Real-time technical pattern recognition
• Financial health scoring

:

1. Rapid Screening
   : As a listed asset management company, TPG has high financial data transparency, suitable for model-based analysis
2. Multi-Dimensional Evaluation
   : Can evaluate valuation, technical aspects, and financial health simultaneously
3. Sentiment Capture
   : Can identify market expectation gaps (e.g., undervaluation signal in April 2024)

:

1. Insufficient Industry Specificity
   : Valuation logic of private equity firms differs significantly from traditional manufacturing
2. Cyclical Blind Spot
   : Cannot fully capture the particularity of private equity investment cycles (e.g., J-curve effect)
3. Lack of Liquidity Premium
   : Difficult to quantify the discount caused by poor liquidity in the private equity secondary market

According to academic research and industry practices [3][4], private equity firm valuation faces unique challenges:

:

• Management fee income (accounting for 78.5%) is relatively stable but has limited growth
• Incentive fee (accounting for 1.6%) is highly volatile and difficult to predict
• Performance realization has significant lag (usually 3-7 year cycle)

:

• High proportion of non-listed company assets in AUM, making fair value difficult to determine
• Valuation relies on internal models, with room for subjective judgment
• Liquidity discount standards vary (usually 20-40% according to research)

Valuation analysis of TPG using DCF model shows [0]:

Scenario	Fair Value	vs Current Stock Price	Evaluation
Conservative Scenario	$24.71	-62.2%	Severely Undervalued
Base Scenario	$15.09	-76.9%	Extremely Undervalued
Optimistic Scenario	$21.42	-67.3%	Severely Undervalued

:

• All scenarios show TPG is “severely undervalued”, but the stock price continues to rise
• Reason for Model Failure
  : The real value drivers of private equity firms (e.g., brand value, deal-making ability, LP relationships) are difficult to quantify into the model
• WACC (14.4%) may not reflect the actual risk characteristics of private equity business

:

1. Expectation Gap Identification
   ★★★★★
   • InvestingPro’s “undervalued” signal in April 2024 successfully captured the market’s pessimistic expectation of the private equity industry
   • When industry sentiment is extreme (e.g., private equity valuation trough in 2022), the quantitative signals of the tool have high reference value

2. Relative Comparison
   ★★★★☆
   • When comparing with peers like Blackstone (BX), KKR, Carlyle (CG), the tool can quickly locate relative valuation advantages
   • Analyst consensus target price $72.50 vs current $65.45, showing 10.8% upside potential [0]

3. Risk Early Warning
   ★★★★☆
   • Technical indicators (MACD, KDJ) can prompt trend changes
   • Currently, TPG is in a sideways震荡, trading range $63.91-$66.29, with no clear direction [0]

:

1. Absolute Valuation Judgment
   ★★☆☆☆
   • “Undervalued” signals from models like DCF may fail for years
   • Current P/E 168.94x far exceeds the reasonable range of traditional valuation frameworks

2. Short-Term Trading Timing
   ★★★☆☆
   • Stock prices of private equity firms are more driven by macro liquidity and industry policies
   • Technical indicators have obvious lag in rapidly changing markets

According to empirical research from web searches [1]:

:

• FRoSTA AG (Germany): 61.33% return after undervaluation signal
• AI concept stocks like NVDA and SMCI: Over 200% increase during AI stock selection strategy period

:

• “Reasonable valuation” signals for high-growth tech stocks often lag behind market revaluation
• Undervaluation signals for cyclical industries may last too long

:

• Accuracy Rate
  : About 60-70% (better effect in industries with clear fundamentals like consumer and industrial)
• Private Equity Industry
  : Accuracy rate may drop to 50-55% (due to special business model)

(InvestingPro etc.)

• Identify abnormal undervalued/overvalued signals
• Focus on deviation from analyst expectations
• Monitor technical trend changes

(Manual Research)

• Evaluate the quality and sustainability of AUM growth
• Analyze the probability of incentive fee realization (depends on exit market environment)
• Examine the historical performance and brand premium of the GP team
• Monitor LP relationships and fundraising capabilities

(Top-Down)

• IPO market activity (affects exits)
• M&A transaction volume and valuation multiples
• Interest rate environment (affects financing costs and discount rates)
• Regulatory policy changes

(Based on multi-dimensional data [0]):

Evaluation Dimension	Score	Explanation
Valuation Attractiveness	★★☆☆☆	P/E 168.94x, DCF model shows severe undervaluation but high model failure risk
Growth Potential	★★★★☆	AUM reaches 245.9 billion USD, raised 6 billion USD for Asian funds in 2024
Profit Quality	★★★☆☆	Net profit margin 1.71%, ROE 3.51%, capital efficiency needs improvement
Technical Aspect	★★☆☆☆	Sideways震荡, no clear direction, support level at $63.91
Analyst Sentiment	★★★☆☆	7 buys, 8 holds, consensus target price $72.50 (+10.8%)

:

• Short-term (3-6 months): High probability of sideways震荡, wait for catalysts (e.g., Q4 performance exceeding expectations)
• Medium-term (6-12 months): If exit market improves, incentive fee release may push stock price above $70
• Risk Points: Valuation repair has been partially completed, further上涨 requires performance兑现

The value of valuation signal tools like InvestingPro in the TPG case is more reflected in

rather than precise valuation. The “undervalued” signal in April 2024 successfully captured the market’s excessive pessimism about the private equity industry, but the subsequent 63% rise in stock price mainly came from:

1. Industry fundamental improvement (interest rate cut expectations, exit market recovery)
2. TPG’s own fundraising success and AUM growth
3. Overall market risk appetite recovery

, so .

---

[0] Gilin API Data - TPG Inc. stock price, financial data, technical analysis, DCF valuation (data as of December 28, 2025)

[1] Investing.com - “Seize the Last Chance! InvestingPro Offers Up to 55% Discount to Unlock AI Stock Selection” (https://hk.investing.com/news/stock-market-news/article-1239271)

[2] Investing.com - “Best Christmas Gift? A Better Investment Portfolio” (https://hk.investing.com/news/stock-market-news/article-1247064)

[3] China Securities Association - “Research on Valuation Business Information Issues and Countermeasures for Private Securities Investment Fund Managers and Custodians” (https://www.csisc.cn/zbscbzw/c100485/202501/fd9edc24f7444c28e983c8db2b46dc6/files/c2ad4ad02d5840738de8900cd5a69bd1.pdf)

[4] Bain & Company - “Proactive Action to Break Through: 2025 Global Private Equity Market Mid-Year Report” (https://www.bain.cn/news_info.php?id=2033)