Industry Analysis Report: NVDA Chip Obsolescence and AI Infrastructure Sustainability

: Reddit discussion (Nov 22, 2025 EST) questioning whether NVIDIA (NVDA) chip obsolescence signals an AI bubble, focusing on depreciation practices, capex sustainability, and ROI on AI investments.

---

The Reddit thread (ticker: NVDA) centers on four core concerns:

• AI companies inflating earnings via extended GPU depreciation schedules.
• Yearly GPU replacement cycles (instead of 5-year capital expenditures) creating unsustainable costs for AI firms.
• Zero or negative ROI on GenAI projects leading to a potential bubble burst.
• Counterargument: Older chips retain value for non-frontier workloads (e.g., inference), mitigating obsolescence risks.

The discussion aligns with broader market jitters in Nov 2025, where the Nasdaq Composite dropped 1.2% amid AI bubble fears [3].

---

Michael Burry publicly accused hyperscalers (Meta, Oracle, Microsoft, Google, Amazon) of extending GPU useful lives to 5–6 years (actual 2–3 years) to inflate earnings [1][2]. For example, Meta saved $2.9B by extending GPU depreciation from 4 to 6 years [1]. This practice improves short-term profitability but risks long-term accounting losses if older chips become obsolete before full depreciation [1].

AI infrastructure spending is surging: Hyperscalers are projected to allocate $342B to capex in 2025 (up 62% YoY) [4], with AI data center capex alone estimated at $387B [5]. NVIDIA’s annual chip releases (e.g., “Ultra” versions) shorten upgrade cycles, turning one-time capital expenses into recurring costs [6]. This is unsustainable for smaller AI firms, though hyperscalers can absorb the burden via scale [1][6].

A MIT study found 95% of organizations achieved zero ROI on GenAI initiatives despite spending $30–40B [7]. This gap between investment and value creation fuels bubble concerns [7].

Older chips can be repurposed for inference (efficiency-focused workloads) instead of frontier training, extending their utility [8]. For example, Google uses older GPUs for internal inference tasks [8].

---

NVIDIA benefits from frequent chip releases (short-term revenue growth) but faces long-term risks if customers cannot sustain capex [6]. Its strategy of equity investments in customers (e.g.,7% stake in CoreWeave, $22.4B OpenAI contracts) ties its success to customer viability [9].

Hyperscalers (Meta, Microsoft) can offset capex via depreciation adjustments and scale [1][4]. Smaller AI firms lack this flexibility, leading to potential market consolidation [7].

CoreWeave uses6-year depreciation (data-driven decision) and has large contracts with OpenAI, but depends on NVIDIA’s chip supply and OpenAI’s spending [2][9].

---

##4. Industry Developments of Note

1. Burry’s Accusations
   : Public criticism of depreciation practices (Nov2025) triggered regulatory scrutiny rumors [1][2].
2. NVIDIA’s Customer Financing
   : $110B in funding commitments to customers (67% of LTM revenue) increases risk exposure [9].
3. Capex Surge
   : AI infrastructure spending now contributes1.1% to U.S. GDP growth [4].
4. Market Jitters
   : Nov2025 stock slump (Nasdaq down1.2%) linked to AI bubble fears [3].

---

##5. Context for Stakeholders

• Investors
  : Evaluate earnings quality (depreciation policies) over reported profits; monitor NVIDIA’s customer investment risks [1][9].
• AI Companies
  : Balance short-term earnings (depreciation) with long-term cash flow; prioritize monetization of AI services to cover capex [1][6].
• NVIDIA
  : Diversify beyond chip sales (software/services) to reduce reliance on recurring hardware upgrades [6][9].
• Regulators
  : May review depreciation standards for AI hardware to address transparency concerns [1][2].

---

##6. Key Factors Affecting Industry Participants

1. Depreciation Standards
   : Regulatory response to Burry’s accusations could impact earnings reporting [1][2].
2. Chip Obsolescence Rate
   : NVIDIA’s release cycle vs. reuse potential for older chips [6][8].
3. Capex Sustainability
   : AI firms’ ability to generate revenue to cover yearly GPU costs [4][5].
4. ROI Improvement
   : Whether GenAI can deliver tangible value to justify infrastructure spending [7].
5. NVIDIA’s Customer Risk
   : Default risks from $110B in funding commitments [9].

---

[1] Cafétech. “The Hidden Ticking Bomb Behind the AI Boom.” Nov2025. https://cafetechinenglish.substack.com/p/the-hidden-ticking-bomb-behind-the
[2] CNBC. “AI GPU Depreciation: CoreWeave, NVIDIA, Michael Burry.” Nov14,2025. https://www.cnbc.com/2025/11/14/ai-gpu-depreciation-coreweave-nvidia-michael-burry.html
[3] CBS News. “Should You Worry About an AI Bubble?” Nov2025. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/artificial-intelligence-ai-bubble-stock-market-economy-dotcom/
[4] JP Morgan Asset Management. “Is AI Already Driving U.S. Growth?”2025. https://am.jpmorgan.com/us/en/asset-management/adv/insights/market-insights/market-updates/on-the-minds-of-investors/is-ai-already-driving-us-growth/
[5] SVCP. “The AI Spending Boom Is Massive But Not Unprecedented.”2025. https://www.svcp.com/the-ai-spending-boom-is-massive-but-not-unprecedented/
[6] Tom’s Hardware. “GPU Depreciation Could Be the Next Big Crisis for AI Hyperscalers.”2025. https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/gpu-depreciation-could-be-the-next-big-crisis-coming-for-ai-hyperscalers-after-spending-billions-on-buildouts-next-gen-upgrades-may-amplify-cashflow-quirks
[7] Yale Insights. “This Is How the AI Bubble Bursts.” Nov2025. https://insights.som.yale.edu/insights/this-is-how-the-ai-bubble-bursts
[8] Stanley Laman. “Why GPU Useful Life Is Misunderstood.”2025. https://www.stanleylaman.com/signals-and-noise/gpus-how-long-do-they-really-last
[9] CITP Blog. “Lifespan of AI Chips: The $300 Billion Question.” Oct2025. https://blog.citp.princeton.edu/2025/10/15/lifespan-of-ai-chips-the-300-billion-question/

---

Disclaimer: This report is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
Data sources are cited for transparency; readers should verify information independently.

Report Date

: Nov24,2025

Prepared By

: Industry Research Expert